Love them, but there’s definitely a difference in formula between the two. Chubby face (the bottom swatch) has a long applicator, more opaque color, and more of a tint. Browny nude (on top) has a much smaller applicator with a much more transparent color and less tint. However, I actually love both of them; they both give a natural look without being drying and the tints both last a long time.

#Browny Nude - nice smooth shade
Bought Browny Nude as I'd never tried brown before - nice formula, but it's a little thin compared to glosses (e.g. tower 28) - rated 5 as I like the colour and formula, it's good for a quick glaze and colour.